Vera is kind, but DHCP seems to be a beeeehatch

In my past few months of running Vera, and after some initial problems with communication and a replacement she’s been kind to me. I’ve been running 15 or so devices, and several daily scenes, including 2 Schlage locks and the WD thermostat. Running .616 is stable, and I haven’t done the Luup yet at all. I’ve been happy, but I just can’t find enough hardware to automate any more effectively. (Hint…need Z-wave TRUE fan controls, speed and dimming, developed, just like proprietary Harbor Breeze, Hunter, etc., devices I can pick up at Lowes/Home Depot.)

However, I am forced to run Vera as my primary router, it was the only way she would behave. Routing, DHCP, everything flows from her and into several switches scattered about the house via Ethernet wiring. This is the essence of my problem…I can’t reposition it and use a different router, tried that already, it loses communications with the findvera service. It’s giving me limited options in troubleshooting.

This is the problem I’m having. In one room I need to upgrade the switch, and I’m replacing an old (pre 2005) 5 port 10/100 Linksys switch with some thing larger, more ports and Gigabit and to get rid of an array of wireless devices. As soon as I replace it, plug devices in, the entire network DHCP blows up. Every device drops and can no longer can connect to the outside or to each other. I’ve used THREE different brands of modern switches, D-Link, Netgear, and Linksys, all Gigabit capable, and when inserting them into the network, I’m seeing all devices in the network lose their IP address in favor of the self-assigned 169 addresses. As soon as I switch back the old 5 port, everything goes back to normal.

I’ve changed out copper back to that bedroom (100% basis), changed ports and switches. The only constant is that when I plug a new switch into that connection, it blows up. Sooner or later that switch is going to die.

Is there something in the Vera hardware which might not like the NUMBER of switches to be too high (The problem switch is #4)? Is here hardware in the modern switches which might be incompatible (However, I run most of my network on a string leaving this room and along the outer wall of the living room. The problem connection is on a 2nd string going the other direction – and it works with the much older 5 port hardware.) I was thinking IP conflict originally, but it works with the old hardware in place!!! So much for an IP conflict.

Seriously, I feel your pain, but strongly urge you to hire a network specialist to iron out what’s happening in your home. There are too many variables involved (router settings, net topology, subnet isolation, tree spanning, etc.) to be addressed effectively here in the Vera forum.

Plus, I’m quite certain some unsuspecting Vera users will be confused as they encounter a discussion involving (network) switches, thinking you mean (Z-Wave light) switches!

Sorry … but hope you see some sense in what I’m suggesting:
Hire someone knowledgeable and hands-on. :slight_smile:

GOOD LUCK!

I second LibraSun suggestion to get a network specialist if you can’t figure it out.

When I got Vera I already had a router, D-Link DIR 855. I certainly I did not want to replace a megabit router (+ wi-fi) with Vera. The ultimate solution for me was to just plug Vera into the ethernet port of my router with the Vera end just being the WAN port so that it could connect to the internet. I set the D-Link router DHCP logic to always assign a fixed internal IP address to Vera. In the advanced setting of Vera I set Internet to DHCP, Firewall – none (since my router provides that function). LAN DHCP server: OFF (since I don’t want Vera to be a DHCP server). Wireless wi-fi set to OFF on Vera.

Since a lot of this network was new to me I had to figure it out. I did a lot of reading of the manuals and searches on the internet. My only advantage was that I’m a software developer, but never tried to figure all of this network stuff out before.

Good Luck!

Leviton does makes a true fan control with speeds… i am using it on 3 of my ceiling fans. Works great. The only catch is that it is just a fan control, not fan and light. Luckily I have 2 switches run to each of my ceiling fans, so I run the leviton fan control for the fan and just a leviton dimmer for the light. Most newer houses have 2 switches run for ceiling fan locations.